Benicia's three city tax and charter measures are split in Solano County's latest unofficial results, posted Nov. 10 at 4:49 p.m., and the two that are linked are moving in opposite directions. The results are not final.
Measure Z, which would set a new real property transfer tax, had 6,745 yes votes to 6,416 no — a 329-vote lead, or about 51.3% yes. But according to the city attorney's impartial analysis, Measure Z "can only be approved if the voters approve Measure Y," and its ordinance will take effect only if both Y and Z are approved by a majority vote.
Measure Y, which would make Benicia a charter city with powers limited to enacting a real property transfer tax, was trailing 7,070 no to 5,792 yes, about 45% yes. Benicia is now a general law city. The city attorney's analysis says the charter is legally necessary for the city to enact the new transfer tax, and that the city's council-manager form of government would continue.
Under Measure Z, real property sales of $2 million or less would be taxed at $4 per $1,000, sales over $2 million up to $10 million at $6 per $1,000, and sales over $10 million at $8 per $1,000, with exemptions including residential homes built before Jan. 1, 2027, that sell for $2 million or less. The city's current rate, set under state law, is $0.275 for each $500, and it would remain in effect if Measure Z fails. The tax is estimated to generate about $230,000 a year, growing to between $3.3 million and $3.8 million by 2050, according to the analysis. Revenue would go to the general fund.
Measure X, which would amend the city's business license tax, led 8,240 to 4,919, about 63% yes. The tax now combines a per-employee charge, a per-unit charge on multifamily rentals and a gross-receipts charge capped at $450 a year for most businesses. Starting Jan. 1, 2027, Measure X would tax gross receipts at rates ranging from $0.25 per $1,000 for general and retail businesses to $1.25 per $1,000 for petroleum businesses, exempt businesses with less than $100,000 in gross receipts, and set an annual maximum that starts at $1,500 and rises 10% a year to $25,000. It would also set a separate 3% tax on the gross receipts of marine terminal businesses, not subject to the cap. First-year revenue is estimated at about $1,612,000. As a general tax, Measure X needs a simple majority.
Ballots remain to be counted. In its Nov. 10 status update, the Registrar estimated that about 1,000 provisional ballots and about 200 damaged ballots remained countywide, with about zero vote-by-mail ballots left, plus about 480 envelopes with signature issues that voters can still cure; it said it may also receive ballots dropped off in other counties. Those estimates are for all of Solano County, not Benicia alone. The next update is scheduled for the end of the day Nov. 12. The county's election calendar lists Dec. 1 as the anticipated certification date and Dec. 3 as the legal deadline.