The City of Franklin is listed with Waste Management, the Village of Raymond and the Town of Norway as parties challenging the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources' denial of Waste Management's wetland permit application for the Metro Landfill expansion, according to the agenda for the city's Waste Facilities Monitoring Committee meeting on Nov. 5. The agenda lists a Milwaukee County Circuit Court case, Waste Management of Wisconsin, Inc., City of Franklin, Village of Raymond and Town of Norway v. Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (No. 26-CV-9669), and a petition by the same parties for a contested case hearing on the DNR's denial order.

The Common Council discussed the matter in closed session on Oct. 20. The council's minutes, approved Nov. 4, describe the session as a conference with legal counsel about litigation over the DNR's denial order "in which the City is likely to become involved." After the council returned to open session at 8:29 p.m., all members present voted "to proceed as discussed in closed session." The minutes don't say what was decided.

Waste Management's proposed Oakwood Expansion would enlarge the Northern Expansion – West landfill at the Metro Recycling and Disposal Facility complex, horizontally and vertically. A hearing notice posted on the city's website says the expansion would cover about 72.25 more acres and permanently fill about 7.66 acres across 11 wetlands, and that most of the waste disposed of there comes from Milwaukee, Waukesha and Racine counties. The notice, for a DNR public informational hearing scheduled at Franklin City Hall on Aug. 25, said the department had made a "tentative determination" to deny the permit.

The landfill matters to the city budget. Under the city's landfill siting agreement, Franklin receives the host-community share of siting revenues, which are based mainly on the volume of material the Waste Management facility accepts, according to the mayor's recommended 2027 budget. The city received $3,319,093 in 2025 and projects about $3.3 million for 2026. The mayor's proposed 2027 budget, which the minutes say is set for a Nov. 17 public hearing and has not been shown here to be adopted, includes $3.15 million: $550,000 for the general fund and $2.6 million for capital or other funds. The budget calls the money "an important source of funding for both operating and capital needs."

In an earlier fact sheet from Waste Management posted on the city's website, which appears to predate the DNR's denial, the company says the landfill has about three to five years of capacity left and that the host communities collectively received nearly $5 million in annual host fees, not Franklin alone. It says Franklin residents can drop off waste there at no charge, and that the benefit could end if the landfill can't expand. These are the company's statements; this report has not independently confirmed the remaining capacity or the effect of a denial.

The city's agenda and minutes refer to the DNR's denial order but don't give its date or the department's reasons. This report is based on the city's agenda, minutes, hearing notice and budget; the final DNR denial order and the filed court and contested-case papers were not obtained, so the claims and merits of the challenge are not described here. The Nov. 5 agenda listed the case for a possible closed session with the committee's lawyer; it does not show what the committee decided.