Pembroke Pines Commissioner Jay D. Schwartz is asking the City Commission to direct the city attorney, working with the city manager and staff, to review the legality and fiscal effects of an ordinance limiting how fast the city's operating spending can grow, and, if it is legally permissible, to draft one for the commission to consider. The motion proposed in his agenda item asks for that review and a draft; it would not put a limit in place by itself.
Under the item, covered city operating expenditures could generally grow each year by no more than the combined percentage increase in the Consumer Price Index and the city's population. The item's example: with inflation of 2.8% and population growth of 0.7%, covered spending could rise by up to 3.5% over the base-year amount. It leaves the choice of price index, base year, population source and calculation method to the city attorney and city manager to recommend.
The item calls the measure a Pembroke Pines Taxpayer Bill of Rights and Fiscal Responsibility Ordinance. It says the ordinance would be modeled "conceptually" on the growth limits in Colorado's Taxpayer's Bill of Rights, Article X, Section 20 of that state's constitution, but drafted to comply with Florida law and the city charter, and that it does not propose adopting Colorado law verbatim.
It would limit spending, not taxes. The item says the ordinance should be structured as an operating-expenditure limit rather than a limit on the commission's power to levy property taxes, and should state that nothing in it restricts that power. It also says nothing in the item is meant to stop a future commission from amending or repealing the ordinance.
The city attorney and city manager would weigh which spending to leave out of the limit, in whole or in part. The item's list of categories to evaluate includes debt service, voter-approved spending, grants and other intergovernmental money, utility and other enterprise funds, capital projects, spending from accumulated reserves, disaster and emergency spending, pensions and other legally required costs, and extraordinary public-safety spending.
To exceed the limit, the item asks the attorney to evaluate an override requiring a four-fifths vote of the commission, with findings on the circumstances, the amount over the limit, the funding source and whether the spending recurs. Each year's budget process would include a calculation comparing proposed covered spending with the maximum allowed, made public early enough for meaningful review before the budget is adopted.
The item asks the city attorney to determine whether such a limit can lawfully be adopted by ordinance. It lists provisions to analyze, including Article VIII, Section 2(b) of the Florida Constitution, state statutes on municipal home rule, budgets and property taxes, Article V of the city charter, and Florida Attorney General Opinion 2010-02, which it describes as concerning municipal operating-expenditure limitations. The item's record lists two attachments: a copy of that opinion and a file whose name refers to the TABOR revenue limit. The attachment names identify neither a draft ordinance nor a staff fiscal analysis; the attachments' contents were not reviewed for this report.
The item was entered in the city's agenda system Sept. 28 and was item 13 on the commission's Oct. 7 agenda. The city's action record for that meeting says no action was taken on it; the meeting's minutes are still marked as a draft. The item's record now lists Nov. 18 as its agenda date. The agenda for that meeting will show whether it is taken up then.
For scale, the city's adopted 2026-27 budget totals $596.9 million across all funds, including a $297.5 million general fund. The item doesn't say how much of that would count as covered operating spending; that would depend on the exclusions and method the city attorney and city manager recommend.