Pembroke Pines city administrators are recommending that the City Commission not move forward, for now, with Commissioner Jay D. Schwartz's proposal for a Taxpayer Bill of Rights and fiscal responsibility ordinance that would limit annual growth in covered city operating expenditures to the combined percentage increase in the Consumer Price Index and the city's population.
The commission's agenda for its 6:30 p.m. meeting Wednesday, Nov. 18, lists both Schwartz's item for discussion and possible action and a commission-requested report on it, which includes a City Attorney's memorandum and a memo from city administration and finance. According to the administration memo, the earlier agenda item requested further review and drafting, and the commission has taken no formal action on it.
Why staff oppose it now
The administration memo says changes associated with Amendment 3 are expected to cost the city about $19 million in revenue in the first year and $33 million in the second, which will require spending reductions, efficiencies and possible changes in service delivery. It says an added spending limit could further restrict the city's ability to respond while maintaining essential services, and that the governor has signaled further property tax legislation.
The memo also says Florida law already requires a balanced budget and that the commission keeps full authority to change proposed spending, pointing to the most recent budget, when a majority voted to add $500,000 for social programming and resident services. It identifies three Florida cities with fiscal limits: Marco Island, Fort Walton Beach and Palm Bay, which limits property tax revenue growth rather than spending.
Legal analysis
In a Nov. 12 memorandum, City Attorney Samuel S. Goren and Assistant City Attorney Karina Nogueras wrote that the proposal is modeled on a Colorado constitutional amendment that is not compatible with Florida law, but that a narrowly crafted ordinance limiting budget expenditures may be legally permissible. Such an ordinance could not directly or indirectly restrict the city's lawful taxing authority, could not conflict with state budget and millage laws, and would have to avoid usurping the city manager's charter powers, the memo says. It notes the proposal did not consider a charter amendment, which would require voter approval.
The meeting has not yet taken place, and the commission's decision is not known.