Crime · Trinity County
Murder counts reduced to manslaughter in fatal Highway 299 crash case; arraignment set Nov. 17
A Trinity County judge ruled Nov. 4 that there is sufficient evidence for a trial in People v. Jose Adelaido Jimenez Garcia, charged in the Jan. 24, 2026 collision on Highway 299 that killed four people and seriously injured another. Judge Eric Heryford reduced the four second-degree murder counts to manslaughter after the prosecution presented no evidence of prior DUI convictions, which are required for murder charges in repeat-DUI crash deaths. Testimony noted Garcia had three prior DUI arrests in Illinois but no proven convictions; CHP investigators said his vehicle's data recorder showed about 61 mph, not the 45 mph he reported, and resort receipts contradicted his account of drinking dinner at the Strawhouse Resort. Victims' family members, including Raven Withey, whose brother Jake Henry died along with Ryan Wiley, Natalie Houston and Craig Houston, expressed concern about the reduced charges. The next court date is an arraignment hearing Tuesday, Nov. 17.